High Sierra Remodeling & Construction logo

An Introduction To Shower vs. Bathtub Resale Value 2024

Before you decide to sell your home, it’s important to think about which features will add the most value. 

If you’re considering a bathroom update, you may be wondering if a shower or bathtub will give you a better return on investment. 

Here’s what the experts say about shower vs. bathtub resale value in 2024.

A freestanding bathtub with a small, fancy table

The Resale Value of Shower vs. Bathtub in 2024

In the world of home improvement, following trends can be both a blessing and a curse. 

Check out these CNBC stories on some of the most beneficial home improvements, With this in mind, let’s take a look at what kind of resale value you can expect from showers versus bathtubs in 2024.

What The Experts Say

According to real estate professionals, shower installations tend to have a higher return on investment than bathtubs. 

This is especially true for homes with limited space; installing a shower instead of a bathtub will give potential buyers the impression that they’re getting more bang for their buck since they’ll have more usable square footage available. 

However, there are still some situations where a bathtub might be preferable; for example, homes with small children or families may benefit from having at least one tub available for bathing little ones.

It’s important to note that your choice between showers and tubs should always consider your preferences as well as those of potential buyers. 

If you’re planning on selling your house within the next few years, then opting for a shower installation may be the smartest choice; however, if you plan on staying put in your current home for at least five years or longer, then it might make sense to install a luxurious bathtub instead.

The Pros and Cons

Showers offer many benefits compared to traditional baths. They save time and energy and conserve water resources due to their low-flow capabilities and shorter duration per shower session. 

Additionally, showers provide an easier way to clean up quickly after workouts or other activities without needing an entire tub’s worth of water just to rinse off sweat or dirt particles.

On the downside, showers lack some of the relaxing qualities that come with taking a soak in hot water (which is why many people prefer baths over showers). 

Also, depending on how much money you’re willing to spend on labor costs and materials while installing them, showers can end up being pricier than standard baths over time due to maintenance fees associated with fixing broken tiles or replacing worn-out grouting material used around them.

A glass walk-in shower in a bath with tile flooring

How to Increase Your Home's Value No Matter What You Choose

Are you looking for a way to increase the value of your home? One of the most effective ways to do so is by renovating your bathroom. 

Whether you choose to install a shower or a bathtub, there are lots of tips and tricks you can use to get the most out of this home improvement project. 

Read on for some helpful advice!

Choose Quality Materials

When it comes to master bath renovations, quality matters. Investing in high-quality materials means that your shower or bathtub will look better, last longer, and be more resistant to damage. 

Sometimes having at least one bathtub or just a shower stall isn’t the main thing buyers want. A good rule of thumb is that higher-quality materials generally cost more upfront but save you money in the long run.

Focus on Design

Your bathroom renovation design is just as important as the materials you use. Take time to consider what kind of aesthetic you want before beginning any renovation work. You should also make sure that the design complements the rest of your home’s interior decor. 

This will help create a sense of unity throughout all areas of your house and make it look more attractive.

Think Long-Term

It’s also important to think about how long-term costs factor into your decision when choosing between a shower or a freestanding tub installation. 

For example, showers are usually cheaper initially but require more ongoing maintenance than baths do due to their smaller size and need for regular cleaning and sealing. 

On the other hand, baths tend to be larger and require less upkeep but typically cost more upfront than walk-in showers do.

The best thing to do: budget wisely and get both a tub and a shower!

Walk-in shower with a freestanding tub


As you can see, there are pros and cons to both walk-in shower and freestanding soaking tub resale values. It really depends on the trends at the time of sale and what potential buyers are looking for in a home. 

However, there are some things you can do to increase the value of your bathroom, no matter which option you choose. If you need help with your bathroom renovation, contact us. 

We would be happy to assist you in creating a space that is not only functional but also adds value to your home.

High Sierra Remodeling & Construction offers professional bathroom remodeling services for homeowners in Reno, Sparks, Sun Valley, and more of Washoe County, NV!

Request a free quote now or call us directly at (775) 242-6405 to discuss about getting the best shower vs. bathtub resale value in 2024!